https://newsletter.po.creamermedia.com
Deepening Democracy through Access to Information
Home / Opinion / Other Opinions RSS ← Back
Africa|Aviation|Export|Infrastructure|Power|Projects|Safety|SECURITY|Service|Services|Equipment|Products|Infrastructure
Africa|Aviation|Export|Infrastructure|Power|Projects|Safety|SECURITY|Service|Services|Equipment|Products|Infrastructure
africa|aviation|export|infrastructure|power|projects|safety|security|service|services|equipment|products|infrastructure
Close

Email this article

separate emails by commas, maximum limit of 4 addresses

Sponsored by

Close

Article Enquiry

Fact-checking former minister Osita Chidoka's claims on Nigeria's 2025 budget, debt and policing


Close

Embed Video

Fact-checking former minister Osita Chidoka's claims on Nigeria's 2025 budget, debt and policing

Africa Check

30th January 2025

By: Africa Check

SAVE THIS ARTICLE      EMAIL THIS ARTICLE

Font size: -+

Well-known Nigerian politician, public servant and administrator Osita Chidoka is a sought-after voice on national issues.

In a January 2025 TV interview on Arise News, Chidoka, also a prominent opposition member and former aviation minister, made several claims following the president's 2025 budget presentation.

Advertisement

We fact-checked them for accuracy.

Claim: Nigeria's budget has grown by only 14%, from U$27-billion in 2014 to $31-billion in 2025.

Verdict: Incorrect

Chidoka said he started the year depressed after hearing the budget for 2025. 

Advertisement

He said that using an exchange rate of N1 600 to the dollar, the country’s projected spending amounts to US$31-billion.

Nigeria’s exchange rate: A complex landscape

In 2024, Nigeria unified its exchange rates, narrowing the gap between official and parallel rates.

However, differences remain. For instance, in November 2024, parliament set the 2025 budget exchange rate at N1 400 to the US dollar. 

But weeks later, president Bola Tinubu announced N1 500 to the dollar while presenting the budget details in parliament. On the same day, the Central Bank of Nigeria’s official rate was N1 538 to the dollar, and by 21 January 2025, the parallel market rate had risen to N1 670/$.

Chidoka didn’t specify the source of his N1 600/$ exchange rate. However, when calculated using parliament’s rate of N1 400 to the dollar, the 2025 budget of N49.74-trillion is estimated at about $35.6-billion – and $33.16-billion based on what Tinubu presented to lawmakers and the budget office’s website – both higher than Chidoka’s claim. 

Nigeria’s budget increased by 20.9% in dollar terms from 2014 to 2025, not 14% as he stated.

Claim: Nigeria’s population has grown at a rate of more than 14% in the past 10 years.

Verdict: Correct

Chidoka argued that Nigeria's 2025 budget failed to reflect population growth, which had outpaced budget increases over the past decade.

Nigeria's population size is debated because there has not been an official census since 2006, with estimates varying among local and international authorities. 

The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) estimated the population at 176.4-million in 2014, rising to 216.7-million in 2022 – a 22.87% increase. 

Prof Ndubisi Akanegbu, an economist at Nile University in northern Nigeria, said that using the US dollar to assess Nigeria's budget growth relative to population growth is reasonable due to its stability, compared to the naira.

Akanegbu said that inflation and currency depreciation over the past decade make local currency comparisons difficult.

Claim: The size of the deficits in the budget has also tripled, so debt servicing has increased.

Verdict: Correct

Chidioka said Nigeria's budget deficit had tripled in 10 years, leading to higher debt repayments. 

A budget deficit is when a government spends more than it takes in. Debt servicing is when a country pays the interest and principal on its domestic and international debt.

Olusegun Ajibola, a professor of monetary economics at Caleb University in Lagos, western Nigeria, said that a budget deficit meant a country had to rely on external sources to finance its budget. 

“The implication of this is that it increases the debt burden, as the country must service both local and international debts. This reduces the capacity of the government to pursue other projects, as a significant portion of funds must be allocated to debt servicing,Ajibola told Africa Check.

In 2014, Nigeria's deficit was N960-billion, rising to N13.08-trillion naira in 2025 – a thirteenfold increase. In US dollar terms, the deficit rose from $6.03-billion in 2014 to $9.34-billion in 2025, an increase of 1.55 times (55%), much less than a threefold increase.

The minister’s claim of a tripling in budget deficit size is inaccurate.

What of debt servicing?

Nigeria allocated N712-billion ($4.45-billion) to debt servicing in 2014, and N16.32-trillion ($11.66-billion) in 2025.

While his budget deficit figure was inaccurate, Chidoka's central claim was about an increase in debt repayment. So his claim is correct.

Claim: The Peoples Democratic Party handed over a clean balance sheet to the All Progressives Congress in terms of international debt and now we are back to where we were before the debt forgiveness.

Verdict: Incorrect

Chidoka claimed that his party, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), left a "clean balance sheet" when it left power in 2015, criticising the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) for increasing Nigeria's debt.

The PDP governed Nigeria from 1999 to 2015 and achieved a landmark debt relief deal in 2006. This agreement with the Paris Club, an informal group of official lenders, reduced Nigeria's external debt by $30-billion, including an $18-billion write-off, after paying $12-billion in eligible debt.

While this deal cleared Nigeria’s Paris Club obligations, the country still owed $5-billion to multilateral and commercial creditors, meaning it was not completely debt-free.

In 2015, when the PDP handed over power, Nigeria's external debt was N2.11-trillion ($10.3-billion), with a total public debt of N12.6-trillion ($63.8-billion).

By 2024, Nigeria’s external debt had risen to N63. 07-trillion (42.9-billion). Chidoka’s claim is incorrect.

Claim: The budget for police in 2025 is about $798-million if you put it in dollars, it's about some N2-trillion, or thereabout.

Verdict: Incorrect

Chidoka claimed that Nigeria's 2025 budget allocated $798-million to the police.

However, according to the budget, a total of N1.2-trillion, equivalent to $857-million at the official exchange rate (N1400/dollar), has been earmarked for the police. 

Earlier in his interview, Chidoka used an exchange rate of N1 600 to the dollar. This translates into about $750-million for the police.

His conversion is still lower than the actual amount stated in the budget.

Claim: The capital vote for the police is just $47-million.

Verdict: Incorrect

Chidoka claimed that $47-million was allocated to the police as a capital vote.

Capital votes are funds allocated for long-term investments like infrastructure, equipment or projects that increase an organisation's capacity, unlike recurrent expenditure, which covers day-to-day operating costs.

According to the budget, N76.6-billion has been allocated for police capital expenditure. 

Using Chidoka's proposed exchange rate of N1 600 to the dollar, the amount comes to $47.9-million. But the minister had sight of the official exchange rate when making his claim.

At the official exchange rate of N1 400/dollar, this is about $54.8-million.

Claim: No state governor in Nigeria receives less than N3-billion annually in security votes.

Verdict: Unproven

Chidoka suggested that state governors could contribute to the police budget. 

To back this up, he claimed that no governor in Nigeria received less than N3-billion annually as security votes.

Security votes are monthly funds given to the president, governors and local government chairpersons for urgent security needs.

They are controversial because they lack transparency, and limited public data makes it hard to verify how the funds are allocated or spent.

We reviewed the 2025 budgets of selected states across Nigeria’s six geopolitical zones, including Kogi, Bauchi, Kano, Anambra and Oyo. We only found security vote allocations in Bauchi’s budget, amounting to N7.5-billion.

No credible data or media reports confirmed the figures Chidoka mentioned.

Security votes should not be confidential because they were meant to ensure public safety, said Emma Chukwuemeka, a professor of public administration at Nnamdi Azikiwe University in Akwa Ibom, southeastern Nigeria.

Claim: In South Africa the budget for the police is about $6-billion.

Verdict: Correct

Chidoka, advocating for increased police funding in Nigeria, claimed South Africa allocated $6-billion and Egypt $204-billion to their police forces. However, he did not specify the year for comparison, making verification difficult.

South Africa has not yet presented its 2025 budget. But the country allocated R113.6-billion ($6.04-billion) to the police in 2024, matching Chidoka's claim.

Claim: The budget for police in Egypt is about $204-billion.

Verdict: Incorrect

Egypt's 2025 budget does not specify allocations for policing. 

A United Nations Children’s Fund (Unicef) report on Egypt's 2023/24 budget shows EGP 105.6-billion ($2.10-billion) was allocated to “public order and security”, covering various services but not detailing the share for policing. In this context, Chidoka's $204-billion figure seems highly inflated.

Claim: Per capita, South Africa’s budget for policing comes to about $100 per person.

Verdict: Correct

Chidoka claimed per capita police funding was $2 in Nigeria, $100 in South Africa and about $1 000 in Egypt.

According to South Africa’s official statistical agency, the country has a population of 63.02-million people. Its 2024 budget allocated R113.6-billion ($6.04-billion) to the police. 

This results in a per capita police funding of approximately $97 at current exchange rates, close to Chidoka’s figure.

Claim: Egypt's budget for policing amounts to almost $1 000 per person.

Verdict: Incorrect

Egypt's population is 107.25-million, according to its national statistics agency. 

Based on Unicef's figure of EGP105.6-billion ($2.1-billion) allocated to “public order and security”, per capita spending is around $19.6, far below Chidoka's $1 000 claim.

Claim: Nigeria's budget for policing amounts to only $2 per person.

Verdict: Incorrect

The United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) estimates Nigeria’s 2024 population at 229.2-million.

With $857-million allocated to police in the budget, per capita funding is $3.74, higher than Chidoka's $2 claim.

Obadiah Smah, a criminology professor at the National Open University of Nigeria in Abuja, said Nigeria, as Africa’s largest economy, should be able to better fund its police force.

He said the 2025 allocation was inadequate, but “if properly utilised, the allocation could change the narrative about police performance and improve Nigeria's ranking among African police forces”.

Claim: As far back as 1985, president Babangida thought about processing cocoa and provided loans to Nigerian companies.

Verdict: Mostly Correct

In 1986, Nigeria’s former military head of state Gen Ibrahim Babangida introduced the structural adjustment programme (SAP) to diversify Nigeria's economy, focusing on sectors like agro-processing, including cocoa processing. 

According to a 1997 International Monetary Fund report, cocoa production grew during the SAP era, increasing from 154 000 tonnes annually (between 1981 and 1985) to 200 000 tonnes. 

The report also notes that Nigeria exported cocoa products such as powder, butter, cake and paste during this period.

A World Bank report notes that in 1988, a refinancing and rediscounting facility, backed by the Central Bank of Nigeria, provided over N500-million to banks, mainly benefiting cocoa exporters. 

Other reforms, such as export insurance, financing guarantees and the removal of state-owned trading companies, also supported exporters.

Claim: Today, Nigeria is exporting raw cocoa instead of exporting butter, cocoa powder and other semi-processed goods.

Verdict: Correct

According to the Nigerian Export Promotion Council, raw cocoa beans make up nearly 90% of Nigeria's $804-million cocoa exports, while semi-processed products such as cocoa butter and cocoa paste contribute $67-million and $28-million, respectively.

A 2024 report from the Trade, Private Sector Development and Employment Facility, a European Commission programme, confirms that Nigeria exports smaller quantities of semi-processed cocoa products compared to raw cocoa beans. 

According to the report, 70 to 80% of cocoa beans are exported raw, while 20–30% are processed into products like cocoa paste, butter, and powder for export and domestic use.

Akeem Tijani, a professor of agricultural economics at Obafemi Awolowo University in Ile-Ife, western Nigeria, confirmed that Nigeria mainly exported cocoa beans but also exported smaller amounts of semi-processed products.

Chidiko’s claim is accurate.

Claim: Despite our rich palm oil heritage in Nigeria, that in 2024 by half year, we've spent $660-million in importing palm oil.

Verdict: Incorrect

Chidoka said that Nigeria spent $660-million importing palm oil, despite its “rich palm oil heritage”.

We traced Chidoka’s claim to a June 2024 statement attributed to Alphonsus Inyang, chair of the National Palm Produce Association of Nigeria. However, Inyang’s figure was $600-million per year. 

Nigeria is a major palm oil producer and has historically been one of the largest producers globally. According to the US Department of Agriculture, the country is the world’s fifth-largest palm oil producer, with Indonesia and Malaysia taking the top two spots.

Despite being a major producer, Nigeria imports large amounts of palm oil, which ranks as the 12th most imported product, according to the June 2024 NBS Foreign Trade in Goods Statistics report.

The NBS data for the first quarter of 2024 shows that Nigeria imported crude palm oil worth N7.47-billion and non-edible palm oil fractions worth N5.15-billion, totalling N12.57-billion ($8.08-million). No palm oil import spending was recorded in the second quarter report

Benjamin Ahmed, a professor of agricultural economics at Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, said Nigeria was struggling to produce enough palm oil.

“Farmers in Nigeria are still using old seedlings instead of the new, higher-yielding varieties that could significantly boost production,” Ahmed told Africa Check.

He added that the government could help by making the new seedlings easier for farmers to obtain and by improving security so that farmers could get to the forests where they needed to farm.

EMAIL THIS ARTICLE      SAVE THIS ARTICLE

To subscribe email subscriptions@creamermedia.co.za or click here
To advertise email advertising@creamermedia.co.za or click here

Comment Guidelines

About

Polity.org.za is a product of Creamer Media.
www.creamermedia.co.za

Other Creamer Media Products include:
Engineering News
Mining Weekly
Research Channel Africa

Read more

Subscriptions

We offer a variety of subscriptions to our Magazine, Website, PDF Reports and our photo library.

Subscriptions are available via the Creamer Media Store.

View store

Advertise

Advertising on Polity.org.za is an effective way to build and consolidate a company's profile among clients and prospective clients. Email advertising@creamermedia.co.za

View options

Email Registration Success

Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to one or more of Creamer Media’s email newsletters. You should start receiving the email newsletters in due course.

Our email newsletters may land in your junk or spam folder. To prevent this, kindly add newsletters@creamermedia.co.za to your address book or safe sender list. If you experience any issues with the receipt of our email newsletters, please email subscriptions@creamermedia.co.za